Dan Watters and Hayden Sherman are really making Batman: Dark Patterns a classic Batman series in the making, and issue #8 proves it. This series continues to be a gritty, street-level detective story that perfectly captures the early, more vulnerable days of the Caped Crusader. It’s raw, it’s visceral, and it’s a fresh take on Gotham and its fledgling protector.
This issue throws Batman deeper into the twisted world of the Rookery, Gotham’s forgotten slums, as he relentlessly hunts for clues in the “Pareidolia” case. Watters’s writing masterfully shows a Batman pushed to the brink of paranoia by the lack of answers about the Red Hood Gang killings. He’s frustrated with dead ends, even snapping at Commissioner Gordon and Dr. Sereika. This isn’t the all-knowing, always-prepared Batman we’re used to, and that’s what makes it so captivating. He’s learning on the job, and you can feel his frustrations.
The opening sequence, with Batman just tearing through goons to find the Red Hood Gang, is badass and a little scary, setting the tone perfectly. And the newspaper clipping by Sherman, calling him the “terror of the Rookery,” is a fantastic creative touch.
DC Comics
The story really shines in its focus on the depravity born from a city that’s given up hope. There’s no supernatural mumbo jumbo here; the horror is purely human, a chilling look at what happens when people are deemed less than human and mercy vanishes. The climax, with a wounded Batman at the mercy of an aging, desperate Red Hood Gang member, is a poignant and terrifying moment that underscores just how dangerous his early career was. Batman isn’t having an easy time; he’s trying to solve this case, and it feels like no one else is interested or wants him to succeed. This position: frustrated, exhausted, and out of options, is a compelling change for Bats that we haven’t seen in a while.
Watters’ portrayal of Batman as a sharp detective is on full display. There’s a great scene where, even as he’s about to be shot, he’s coolly analyzing the range, location, weapon, era, and potential identity of his attacker, and Sherman illustrates this perfectly. The revelation of who “The Red Hood Gang” actually is provides an interesting twist that will leave you excited to see what happens next.
Hayden Sherman’s artwork is still the undeniable visual powerhouse of this series. His distinct style perfectly captures Gotham’s gothic drama. The panel layouts are dynamic and disorienting, cranking up the trippy, paranoid vibe of the “Pareidolia” arc. The chase scene between Batman and those street kids is a highlight of this issue. Sherman absolutely nailed it, packing in so many different angles and incredible details.
DC Comics
Tríona Farrell’s coloring is just as crucial, with muted colors that are bold without being flashy. Every color choice feels meticulously tailored to the script’s emotional beats. The collaboration between Watters’ tight writing and Sherman and Farrell’s exceptional art creates an immersive and unsettling experience that feels genuinely fresh in today’s crowded Batman market.
Batman: Dark Patterns has earned its praise for being a grounded, smart, and detective-driven story, and issue #8 is no exception. It’s a testament to the idea that you don’t always need the whole rogues’ gallery or complex multiversal plots to tell a compelling Batman story. Sometimes, all it takes is a young, less-experienced Batman, a brutal mystery, and a descent into the forgotten, dark corners of Gotham, all brought to life by a creative team that’s firing on all cylinders. This issue is a solid continuation of what is undoubtedly one of the best Batman books currently on the shelves.
‘Batman: Dark Patterns’ #8 Batman’s Descent into Gotham’s Grimy Soul
Batman: Dark Patterns has earned its praise for being a grounded, smart, and detective-driven story, and issue #8 is no exception. It’s a testament to the idea that you don’t always need the whole rogues’ gallery or complex multiversal plots to tell a compelling Batman story. This issue is a solid continuation of what is undoubtedly one of the best Batman books currently on the shelves.
